How Shoes Should Fit.
How shoes should fit: toe room, width, heel slip, when to try them on, what a cobbler can fix, and where your trouser hem should meet the shoe.

The fit in 30 seconds.
Check these in order. The first ones are the hardest to alter.
- 01
Length
Leave about a thumb width between your longest toe and the end of the shoe. Length is the one thing nobody can change later.
Test: Standing, laces tied: 1 to 1.5 cm (0.4 to 0.6 in) in front of your longest toe, which may be the second toe.
- 02
Width
The ball of your foot sits in the widest part of the shoe, without bulging over the sole.
Test: Standing, the upper does not bulge past the edge of the sole at the little toe, and you can pinch a little leather across the top of the toes.
- 03
Flex point
The shoe bends where your foot bends.
Test: Up on your toes, the crease forms across the ball of your foot, not in front of your toes or behind the ball.
- 04
Heel
Your heel stays in the shoe when you walk.
Test: In a new leather shoe, the heel lifts no more than about 0.5 cm (0.2 in) per step. In sneakers it should not lift at all.
- 05
Instep
Laces close with a gap between the eyelet rows, and a loafer holds your foot without cutting in.
Test: Oxford or derby: the lace facings sit 0.5 to 1 cm (0.2 to 0.4 in) apart once tied. Loafer: no red line across the instep after 10 minutes.
- 06
Toe box
Your toes lie flat and can move.
Test: You can lift and wiggle all five toes inside the shoe, and nothing presses on the top of the toe joints.
- 07
Trouser hem
Your trouser hem meets the shoe without piling up on it.
Test: At the front, the hem touches the top of the shoe with no break or a slight one. At the back, it covers about half of the heel counter.
A shoe fits when there is a thumb width of room past your longest toe, the ball of your foot sits in the widest part of the shoe, and your heel stays put when you walk. It should feel comfortable in the shop. Shoes that hurt on day one rarely stop hurting.
Try them on in the afternoon
Your feet swell over the day, and more after a long walk or a flight. A shoe that fits at 9 a.m. can pinch by evening. Shop in the afternoon, and wear the socks you plan to wear with the shoes: thin dress socks for dress shoes, thicker ones for boots and sneakers.
Most people have one foot slightly larger than the other. Try on both shoes and fit the larger foot.
Test them in under a minute
- Stand up with the laces tied. Press the toe with your thumb to find your longest toe. You want about a thumb width, 1 to 1.5 cm (0.4 to 0.6 in), of space in front of it.
- Walk ten steps on a hard floor, not the carpet. A new leather shoe can lift a little at the heel, about 0.5 cm (0.2 in). More than that, or any slip in a sneaker, means the heel is too wide or the shoe too long.
- Go up on your toes. The shoe should crease across the ball of your foot. If it creases in front of your toes, the shoe is too long. If it creases behind the ball, it is too short.
- Crouch down. Your toes should not jam into the front, and the sides should not cut into your little toe.
Break-in myths
"Leather stretches" is half true. Leather softens and molds across the width and over the instep, a few millimeters at most. It never gets longer. A shoe that is too short will stay too short, and a cobbler cannot stretch length into it.
"Buy them tight, they'll loosen up" applies only to a slight pressure across the ball of the foot in full-grain leather. It does not apply to synthetic uppers, patent leather or most sneakers, which keep their shape.
Break-in should mean the sole flexes more and the leather stops feeling stiff. It should not mean blisters for three weeks.
What a cobbler can fix
A cobbler or an insole can fix small problems cheaply: heel grips for heel slip, a tongue pad for a shoe that is half a size long, stretching for a leather shoe that pinches across the width, spot-stretching for a bunion or a little toe. These are worth doing.
Length cannot be fixed. Neither can a shoe that is a full size too big, because it will crease in the wrong place no matter how much padding you add. Check length first, before you fall for the shoe.
Slim, regular and relaxed trousers
How the trouser hem meets the shoe depends on the cut of the trousers.
Slim trousers and jeans should touch the top of the shoe at the front with no break, so the leg ends cleanly. With sleek dress shoes or low sneakers, this is the sharpest line.
Regular or straight trousers can have a slight break: one soft fold where the hem rests on the shoe. At the back, the hem covers about half of the heel counter.
Relaxed and wide trousers are worn longer, with a fuller break, and work best with heavier shoes such as chunky sneakers, boots or lug-sole derbies. A slim, low dress shoe under a wide leg looks lost. The difference between an intentionally chunky shoe and one that is simply too big: the chunky shoe still has a thumb of room at the toe and creases at the ball of your foot. The too-big shoe creases near your toes and slips at the heel.
When standard sizes fail you
Wide feet. Look for brands that sell widths (E, EE, EEE in US sizing) rather than sizing up in length. Sizing up gives you width at the ball but leaves your heel slipping.
High instep. Derbies, with their open lacing, fit a high instep better than oxfords. Loafers are the hardest.
Flat feet or high arches. Leave room for an insole. Try shoes on with the insole in.
Large feet. If you are over about US 12, sizes run out quickly in store. Measure your foot length in centimeters and compare it with each brand's size chart instead of trusting the number.
Related guides
Get the hem right with how dress pants should fit, how jeans should fit and how chinos should fit. For a second opinion on your outfit, try the fit check.
Can a tailor fix it?
Your heel lifts out of the shoe with every step.
The heel cup is wider than your heel, or the shoe is a touch long.
What to do: Have a cobbler fit heel grips, or stick them in yourself. A thin insole also helps.
Your foot slides forward and your toes hit the front on stairs.
The shoe is about half a size long, or the instep is too roomy.
What to do: Add a tongue pad under the tongue or a half insole to hold the foot back.
Leather shoes pinch across the ball of the foot.
The shoe is slightly narrow for your foot.
What to do: A cobbler can stretch leather across the width by a few millimeters.
One spot presses, often the bunion joint or the little toe.
Your foot has a bump that the last does not allow for.
What to do: Ask a cobbler to spot-stretch that area of the leather.
The sides bulge over the sole, or the shoe is synthetic or patent and tight.
The shoe is a full width too narrow, or made of a material that barely stretches.
What to do: A cobbler can try stretching, but synthetics and patent leather often spring back. Return it if you still can.
Your toes press down from the top of the toe box.
The toe box is too low for your toes.
What to do: Height stretching works only a little on leather. A thinner insole gives a few millimeters.
Your toes touch the end of the shoe when you stand.
The shoe is too short.
What to do: Return it. Stretching adds width, not length.
There is more than a thumb width of empty space past your toes.
The shoe is a full size or more too long.
What to do: Return it. Pads hide half a size at most, and the shoe will crease in the wrong place.
Prices are typical ranges at an independent tailor in the US and vary by city. Check another garment →
Asked often.
- Should new shoes be tight so they can break in?
- Only a little across the width, in leather. Leather softens and molds to your foot, but the length never changes, so a shoe that hurts your toes in the shop will keep hurting.
- What time of day should I try on shoes?
- In the afternoon or evening. Feet swell over the day, so a shoe that fits at 9 a.m. can pinch by evening.
- How much room should be in front of my toes?
- About a thumb width, 1 to 1.5 cm (0.4 to 0.6 in), in front of the longest toe while standing. Running and hiking shoes need the full 1.5 cm because your foot slides forward downhill.
- My feet are different sizes. Which one do I fit?
- Fit the larger foot. Then add an insole or tongue pad to the shoe on the smaller foot.
- Are shoe sizes the same across brands?
- No. Sizes vary between brands and between lasts from the same brand. Measure your foot length in centimeters, check the size chart, and try them on.








